diff --git a/Questionable/Controller/Steps/Interactions/UseItem.cs b/Questionable/Controller/Steps/Interactions/UseItem.cs
index 1fd7b6aa..8868f811 100644
--- a/Questionable/Controller/Steps/Interactions/UseItem.cs
+++ b/Questionable/Controller/Steps/Interactions/UseItem.cs
@@ -131,7 +131,7 @@ internal static class UseItem
                 }
 
                 int itemCount = inventoryManager->GetInventoryItemCount(ItemId);
-                if (itemCount == _itemCount)
+                if (!_usedItem && itemCount == _itemCount)
                 {
                     // TODO Better handling for game-provided errors, i.e. reacting to the 'Could not use' messages. UseItem() is successful in this case (and returns 0)
                     logger.LogInformation(